| Name | Pos | Salary | Through | Years Left | Notes | Years in Majors |
| D. Jeter | SS | $19,000,000 | 2010 | 7 years left | | 10 years |
| A. Rodriguez | 3B | $17,000,000 | 2011 | 8 years left | | 11 years |
| M. Mussina | SP | $16,000,000 | 2007 | 4 years left | | 14 years |
| K. Brown | SP | $15,000,000 | 2005 | 2 years left | | 17 years |
| J. Giambi | 1B | $14,000,000 | 2009 | 6 years left | | 10 years |
| G. Sheffield | RF | $13,000,000 | 2006 | 3 years left | | 17 years |
| B. Williams | CF | $12,000,000 | 2006 | 3 years left | | 14 years |
| M. Rivera | CL | $10,890,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 10 years |
| J. Vazquez | SP | $10,500,000 | 2007 | 4 years left | | 7 years |
| J. Posada | C | $9,000,000 | 2007 | 4 years left | | 10 years |
| J. Contreras | SP | $9,000,000 | 2006 | 3 years left | | 2 years |
| H. Matsui | LF | $7,000,000 | 2005 | 2 years left | | 2 years |
| S. Karsay | MR | $5,000,000 | 2006 | 3 years left | | 8 years |
| T. Gordon | MR | $3,630,000 | 2005 | 2 years left | | 16 years |
| K. Lofton | CF | $3,100,000 | 2005 | 2 years left | | 14 years |
| P. Quantrill | MR | $3,000,000 | 2006 | 3 years left | | 13 years |
| J. Lieber | SP | $2,450,000 | 2005 | 2 years left | | 10 years |
| T. Lee | 1B | $2,000,000 | 2005 | 2 years left | | 5 years |
| F. Heredia | MR | $1,800,000 | 2006 | 3 years left | | 9 years |
| R. Sierra | LF | $1,000,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 18 years |
| M. Cairo | 2B | $900,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 9 years |
| J. Flaherty | C | $780,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 12 years |
| E. Wilson | 2B | $700,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 8 years |
| T. Clark | 1B | $380,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 10 years |
| J. Depaula | MR | $302,550 | 2004 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 1 years |
| B. Crosby | LF | $301,400 | 2004 | 1 years left | Possible Arbitration, 156 more days of service needed this year. | 2 years |
| B. Prinz | MR | $300,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $300,000) | 4 years |
| B. Halsey | SP | $300,000 | 2004 | 1 years left | Possible Arbitration, 139 more days of service needed this year. | 2 years |
| C. Manning | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| F. Seguignol | 1B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 5 years |
| J. Marquez | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| D. Borrell | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| A. Graman | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| C. Wang | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| H. Bush | 2B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| S. Marsonek | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| S. Henn | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| E. Sierra | CL | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| S. Proctor | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| E. Candelario | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| F. Tejeda | 2B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| A. Phillips | 3B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| M. Vento | CF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| D. Parrish | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| J. Arias | SS | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| T. Battle | RF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| T. Beam | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| R. Cano | 2B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| T. Clippard | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| R. Currier | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| M. Desalvo | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| J. Drobiak | 1B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| J. Garcia | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| R. Guillen | RF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| E. Harris | RF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| B. Julianel | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| H. Made | 2B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| B. Myrow | 3B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| D. Navarro | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| M. Phillips | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Pope | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| E. Quezada | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| B. Sardinha | CF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Smith | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Sprowl | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| E. Duncan | 3B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Girardi | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 14 years |
| T. Houston | 3B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 7 years |
| J. Mann | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 4 years |
| D. Bragg | LF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 10 years |
| O. Funtes | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| D. Shepard | CL | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| J. Rodriguez | RF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| C. Bean | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| S. Torrealba | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| T. Sturtze | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 8 years |
| K. Hooper | 3B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| J. Anderson | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 1 years |
| R. Ramirez | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| M. Schiller | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| P. Varela | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| D. Baker | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| D. Salazar | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| C. Sanches | LF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
|